Charles Forbes Rene de Montalembert Born : March 18, 1810 Died : March 13, 1870 Browse All Authors Top 3 quotes by Charles Forbes Rene de Montalembert Without a Sabbath, no worship; without worship, no religion; and without religion, no permanent freedom. Charles Forbes Rene de Montalembert sabbath permanent worship It is not the victory that makes the joy of noble hearts; but the combat. Charles Forbes Rene de Montalembert victory heart joy Where there is a wine-shop, there are the elements of disease and the frightful source of all that is at enmity with the interests of the workmen. Charles Forbes Rene de Montalembert enmity elements wine